Killing Cassidy Read online

  Table of Contents

  By Jeanne M. Dams

  Title Page

  Copyright

  Dedication

  Author’s Note

  Chapter 1

  Chapter 2

  Chapter 3

  Chapter 4

  Chapter 5

  Chapter 6

  Chapter 7

  Chapter 8

  Chapter 9

  Chapter 10

  Chapter 11

  Chapter 12

  Chapter 13

  Chapter 14

  Chapter 15

  Chapter 16

  Chapter 17

  Chapter 18

  Chapter 19

  Chapter 20

  Chapter 21

  Chapter 22

  Chapter 23

  Chapter 24

  Chapter 25

  Chapter 26

  By Jeanne M. Dams

  The Dorothy Martin Mysteries

  THE BODY IN THE TRANSEPT

  TROUBLE IN THE TOWN HALL

  HOLY TERROR IN THE HEBRIDES

  MALICE IN MINIATURE

  THE VICTIM IN VICTORIA STATION

  KILLING CASSIDY

  TO PERISH IN PENZANCE

  SINS OUT OF SCHOOL

  WINTER OF DISCONTENT

  A DARK AND STORMY NIGHT

  THE EVIL THAT MEN DO

  THE CORPSE OF ST JAMES’S

  MURDER AT THE CASTLE

  KILLING CASSIDY

  A Dorothy Martin Mystery

  Jeanne M. Dams

  This ebook is copyright material and must not be copied, reproduced, transferred, distributed, leased, licensed or publicly performed or used in any way except as specifically permitted in writing by the publishers, as allowed under the terms and conditions under which it was purchased or as strictly permitted by applicable copyright law. Any unauthorised distribution or use of this text may be a direct infringement of the author’s and publisher’s rights and those responsible may be liable in law accordingly.

  First published in the United States of America in 2000

  by Walker Publishing Company, Inc.

  eBook first published in 2013 by Severn House Digital

  an imprint of Severn House Publishers Ltd.

  Copyright © 2000 by Jeanne M. Dams

  The right of Jeanne M. Dams to be identified as the Author of this work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright, Designs & Patents Act 1988.

  ISBN-13: 978-1-4483-0093-8 (ePub)

  Except where actual historical events and characters are being described for the storyline of this novel, all situations in this publication are fictitious and any resemblance to living persons is purely coincidental.

  This ebook produced by

  Palimpsest Book Production Limited,

  Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland.

  This book is dedicated to Luci Zahray, whose encyclopedic knowledge of toxicology has helped me with many plots, and who worked this one out virtually single-handedly. She is an avid Sherlockian and a mystery fan without parallel, and I consider myself fortunate to call her my friend.

  Author’s Note

  Most of this book is set near Madison, Indiana, a beautiful little town on the Ohio River. My husband and I love Madison and have visited there frequently. I’ve rearranged its geography slightly, but I’ve tried to preserve its unique flavor.

  I’ve erected the town of Hillsburg and Randolph University a few miles northwest of Madison. Neither town nor university bears any resemblance to Hanover or Hanover College, which are real places just west of Madison.

  The Tour of Homes is a real Madison event, held every other October and every Christmas. I’ve altered some details of the October tour to suit my purposes, and moved at least one house so as to fit nicely into the tour, but every house I mention really exists. So far as I am aware, no murderers have ever tried to elude their pursuers during the tour—but of course one never knows.

  Beanblossom, Indiana, is a real place, but in a different part of the state. It has no church even remotely like the Full Gospel Church of the Redeeming Spirit, nor have I ever encountered, anywhere, any church like the Church of the All-Consuming Fire—thank goodness.

  1

  ALAN, look at this!”

  I waved the letter I held in my hand. One of the nice little benefits of living in England is the mail. It arrives early enough in the morning to be consumed with breakfast, and with a predictable regularity that is unknown in America. Or at least it’s nice when there’s something more interesting than bills, as there certainly was this morning.

  Alan lowered the Times and took the letter, while I poured myself a second cup of tea and spread marmalade on my toast. We were breakfasting in our kitchen, the coziest room in the Jacobean cottage we both love so much. The sun shone through leaded glass windows and sparkled on the geraniums on the windowsill. Esmeralda and Samantha, our two cats, were outside napping in the sun and trying to ignore the raucous cries of the magpies. The cats hate the magpies, and I have to admit myself that they’re messy, noisy, thieving rascals, but I can’t help liking them; they’re so handsome in their black-and-white livery, and so very English.

  Alan read my letter aloud. “‘Dear Mrs. Nesbitt.’” He paused for a moment to smile at me. “Has a nice ring to it, doesn’t it?”

  I grinned back idiotically. We’d been married nearly two years now, but we still weren’t quite used to it. One might think that a pair of widowed sixty-somethings would react to marriage with more decorum than is usually exhibited by sweet young things. One might be wrong. I don’t actually use my husband’s name, feeling more comfortable with the name I used for over forty years, but people often make the natural mistake, and Alan was right. It sounded good.

  He went on. “‘It is my sad duty to report to you the death of Dr. Kevin Cassidy, who was, I understand, a very old friend of you and your late husband.’”

  “In both senses,” I replied to his quirked eyebrow. “Frank and I had known him forever, and he was in his nineties. The chairman of biology at Randolph when Frank first went to teach there, and one of our dearest friends. He retired ages ago, of course. He was very kind when Frank died, but when I moved over here I—oh, I don’t know, I didn’t write very often, and neither did he, and after a while we lost touch, except for Christmas cards. I suppose it’s been over a year. …” I sighed. Why do we forget about our friends’ mortality? Why do we assume we can always make up for lost time? Another sigh. “Go on, get to the next part.”

  “‘… pneumonia … not unexpected … merciful release … rather an unusual clause in his will.’ Ah, we’re getting to it. ‘Bequeathed to you the sum of five thousand dollars, tax free, with the stipulation that you must return to Hillsburg to collect it. Should you fail to comply with this stipulation, the money is to go to the Full Gospel Church of the Redeeming Spirit in Beanblossom.’ What in the name of all that’s holy is that?”

  I made a face, “I’m not sure holiness has anything to do with it. They do various odd things with snakes, I’m told, if indeed the church is still in existence. Beanblossom is a tiny town not far from Hillsburg. More of a wide spot in the road, actually. Nothing thrives in Beanblossom, or not for long. But the point is that dear old Kevin and I used to have a sort of standing joke about the place and its remarkable theology. It was rather rude of us, I suppose, but he knew quite well that one way to make sure I accepted his bequest was to threaten to give the money to them. I wonder what they’d do with it? Buy bigger and better snakes?”

  Alan grinned and went back to the letter. “‘—not a large sum of money, of course, but Dr. Cassidy also stipulated that your travel expenses were to be paid by his estate, should you choose to accept his conditions.’ This fellow ought t
o be writing television scripts.”

  “Woman. Look at the signature.”

  “Ah, yes. Michelle Carmichael. To continue: ‘In order to comply with these conditions, you must make arrangements to arrive in Hillsburg within one month of his death, which took place yesterday.’ But the letter’s dated ninth December—”

  “No, it isn’t. American-style dating. The month comes first. Nine twelve means September twelfth. Four days ago. So the poor old dear died last Monday. Alan, I’m so sorry I’ll never see him again. I owe him a lot.”

  I took a sip of my cold coffee and leaned my elbows on the table, remembering. “We never had children, Frank and I. You know that. But I did have a—I was never sure what to call it. A false pregnancy or a miscarriage or something. For nearly three months I had all the symptoms of pregnancy, and we were wildly happy. I was over forty and we had just about given up hope. I’d been to the doctor and had the test, and it had come back negative, but the tests are sometimes wrong, and I was so sure. And then—well, then the dream fell apart. I had what almost amounted to a hemorrhage, and my body went back to normal again.”

  I sipped some more coffee. Alan moved his hand to cover mine. “My body went back to normal, but not my mind. I couldn’t stop crying. I would go to school in the morning, dreading a day of teaching, and I would see all those lovely, healthy children, and I couldn’t stand it. After a month or so I was in such a state I had to take a leave of absence, but then I was alone all day with nothing to do but mourn. I couldn’t talk to Frank about it. He was unhappy, too, but he buried himself in his work, the way a man will.

  “I really think I would have collapsed completely if it hadn’t been for Kevin. He saw Frank every day, of course, and he knew something was wrong. So he came and made me tell him what it was. And then he listened. Dear man, I cried all over him, and he hated to see women cry, but he just handed me Kleenex until I was finally all cried out. Then he made me take something for the raging headache I had after all that crying, and then he gave me a good old-fashioned talking-to. Told me it wasn’t the end of the world, that I had a job I loved and a husband who adored me and a beautiful world to live in, and I should count my blessings. I was in no mood to listen to good advice, but he did something more practical. He went and got the liveliest, naughtiest kitten he could find and gave it to me.”

  Alan chuckled.

  “A kitten refuses to be ignored. If I was tempted to spend the morning in bed feeling sorry for myself, the little demon would come and pounce on my toes with those razor-sharp claws. Or she’d climb the curtains or knock things off the dresser or—oh, you know all the kinds of trouble kittens can find to get into. So I’d have to get out of bed, and I’d have to get dressed, too. Jezebel’s claws would go right through a bathrobe.”

  “Jezebel?”

  “Because she was so wicked and so beguiling. Once she had my undivided attention, she’d climb into my lap and lick my hand and be such a sweet kitty. Then she’d purr herself to sleep and nap until she was refreshed and ready to torment me again. She wore me out, chasing after her and cleaning up when she created some disaster—which was frequently—and I began to sleep again nights. And when Frank came home, we’d have Jezebel’s antics to laugh about, instead of spending the evening in painful silence avoiding the topic we couldn’t discuss. After a couple of weeks I was more than ready to get back to the classroom and thirty-seven children who could not, between them, create anything like as much chaos as three pounds of frisky feline.

  “So you see, Kevin saved my sanity. He was an invaluable friend. And unless he failed badly in the last year or so, that part about ‘a merciful release’ is hogwash. His memory was better than mine’s been for years, and he still lived alone. Managed very well, too.”

  “I suppose his neighbors helped.”

  “Hah! He was the one who helped them. Not that he had many close neighbors; he lived out in the country. But he still drove, the last I knew, and he’d go in to town for groceries and bring some back for the woman next door if she was too busy to go for herself—that kind of thing. It’s just like him to give me a last, nice little surprise, and I feel guilty as anything for not having kept in closer touch with him.”

  “Well, then, you’ll want to comply with his last request, won’t you?” Alan squeezed my hand and pretended not to notice the tear I had to wipe from my cheek.

  “Well—I know it’s ridiculously short notice, but—you would go with me, wouldn’t you? You’re not off on some international jaunt or other?”

  For Alan, though he retired some time ago as chief constable of Belleshire, is still asked to contribute his expertise to police forces all over what used to be the British Empire, and I never knew for certain when he’d be hopping off to Africa or India or wherever.

  “My dear, I am entirely at your disposal. Let’s plan to stay on a bit after you’ve dealt with your business—at our own expense, of course—and make it a holiday. You write back to this solicitor or whatever she is, and tell her you’re coming.”

  I barely heard him. “Alan.” I stopped, groping after an elusive thought, and he looked at me quizzically. “Why do you suppose he wanted me to come back? I don’t understand it. If he’d wanted to see me about something—though I can’t imagine what—he’d have written, or phoned. But this way, making me come home after he’s dead—it’s odd. Bizarre. Almost—ghoulish.” I shivered.

  “Calm down, darling. He probably just wanted to give you a little treat, and chose this way of doing it so that you weren’t likely to refuse.”

  “It’s not like him,” I insisted. “He was always generous, but never manipulative. He was full of good advice when someone needed it, but he never tried to make anyone take it. This is out of character. I’m not really sure I like it, after all.”

  “You’re speculating ahead of your data, my dear. Sherlock Holmes warned us about that. Doubtless all will be made clear when we get there.”

  I’d never before organized an international journey on a few days’ notice, but between the two of us, we managed. Alan bought our tickets at the exorbitant rates charged last-minute fliers. I took a leave of absence from my volunteer job at the Cathedral Bookshop and arranged with our next-door neighbor to look after the cats. And a sunny Wednesday afternoon in late September found us standing, somewhat stiff and tired, in the international terminal at Chicago’s O’Hare Airport.

  Alan yawned and dragged a hand across his cheek. “I could do with a shave.”

  “I could do with a nap.”

  In the end, after Alan had picked up the rental car and driven cautiously to our hotel, he thought of a better way to spend an hour or two. Afterward, relaxed and rejuvenated, we had a leisurely dinner and fell into bed.

  I woke well before dawn the next morning and lay quietly, trying not to wake Alan. Something about his breathing, though, seemed a little too quiet.

  “Alan,” I whispered, “are you awake?”

  “For the past hour, love. I didn’t want to disturb you.”

  I sat up on one elbow. “Are you hungry?”

  “Not particularly.”

  “Then let’s go! The coffee shop here won’t be open yet, but we can eat on the road. I know a place in South Bend—the food’s wonderful, though you won’t like the coffee.”

  “Happy to be home, are you?” He swung his feet out of bed and headed for the bathroom.

  “Oh, Alan, I hadn’t realized how much I wanted to show you! You can have the shower first, but hurry up!”

  I drove. We were early enough to escape Chicago’s horrendous rush-hour traffic, and a little over two hours later we were digging into an enormous breakfast at a pancake house in South Bend.

  “You’re English, aren’t you?” The waitress smiled as she poured us a second cup of the sort of coffee my family used to call “damaged water.” “I can tell by your accents.”

  Accents, plural? I gave Alan a shocked look. He patted my hand. “I’m English. My wife is American.”


  “Yeah? You sound just alike to me. Can I get you anything else?”

  “Just the bill, please.”

  “Here you go. You pay up front. Have a nice day.”

  “Alan, I don’t sound English!” I said indignantly, once we were back in the car.

  “Not to me, love, but I expect you do to her. You can’t expect to spend three years in a country and not absorb some of its influence. Careful!”

  I swerved back to my side of the road and tried to ignore the angry shouts from the other driver. Clearly I had some adjustments to make.

  Cincinnati is the closest major airport to my hometown in southern Indiana, but we’d chosen to fly into Chicago. The fare was a good deal cheaper, for one thing, and besides, I wanted to show Alan lots of my home state. So we meandered south from South Bend through lush farming country, acres of golden cornfields and green-yellow soybeans. Leaves were just beginning to turn in the northern part of the state. Here and there we saw a sumac hedge blazing with red and orange, a maple beginning to turn yellow. With the rising of the sun the day had turned almost hot. The cloudless sky was an intense shade of blue that I have seen only in the Midwest.

  I fumbled for the air-conditioning controls and sighed with contentment. Alan looked out the window and smiled in agreement.

  We stayed off the interstates. Superhighways are great for getting places in a hurry, but if you want to see anything, slower roads win hands down. So we went through Indianapolis, rather than around. The traffic gave us plenty of time to see the Circle and the Statehouse and the various monuments and, it must be admitted, the seamier aspects of town as well. We stopped in Columbus, just a little way south, to have some lunch and walk off too much driving, enjoying the famous, varied architecture of the town. Alan had to pull me back to the curb as I crossed one street; I’d looked the wrong direction for traffic and nearly gotten run over.

  It was only a short drive then, along a narrow state highway, to Hillsburg.

  We’d booked our hotel room from England and had been warned that we had to make other arrangements after a few days. “That next weekend’s a home game,” the desk clerk had said. I’d had to explain to Alan.